Risk Margins in Solvency Valuation

Purpose of a Risk Margin

A best-estimate liability values the expected future cash flows within the valuation model. In a simplified solvency valuation, the risk margin is an additional amount representing the projected cost of holding capital against the risks associated with those obligations as they run off. The risk margin is not another estimate of expected claims, nor is it a fixed percentage of the best-estimate liability.

The calculation requires a projection of future capital requirements, a cost-of-capital rate, and discount factors for the projected cost payments. The projection and timing conventions must be clear: a capital amount at one date and a cost paid at a later date do not have the same present value as a cost paid immediately. The examples below use hypothetical portfolios and simplified assumptions for illustration.

Definition: Under a simplified cost-of-capital approach, the risk margin at time 0 is the present value of the future costs of holding projected capital requirements. If $C_t$ is the capital requirement used for the cost payment at time $t$, $c$ is the annual cost-of-capital rate, and $D_t$ is the discount factor from time $t$ to time 0, then

RM_0=\sum_{t=1}^{n} c\,C_tD_t.

For a constant effective annual discount rate $r$, with each cost paid at the end of its year, $D_t=(1+r)^{-t}$. Under the simplified definition used here, technical provisions equal the best-estimate liability plus the risk margin.

Model and Timing Assumptions

The formula is only as meaningful as its assumptions. In this tutorial, $C_t$ is a projected capital requirement in dollars (or in thousands of dollars, when stated), and $c$ is a nonnegative annual rate applied to that requirement to determine a cost for the period. Each cost $cC_t$ is paid at the end of year $t$. The projection ends at year $n$; any later capital requirement is assumed to be zero. The discount factors apply to the dates at which those costs are paid.

With a constant effective annual rate $r$, the discount factor at the end of year $t$ is $(1+r)^{-t}$. If annual rates differ, the discount factor is the reciprocal of the accumulated growth factors through the payment date. For example, if the annual rates for years 1, 2 and 3 are $r_1,r_2,r_3$, then $D_3=1/[(1+r_1)(1+r_2)(1+r_3)]$.

The model does not say that every solvency framework uses exactly these inputs, conventions, or even this simplified formula. A valuation must use the required definition and assumptions for its particular purpose. In the problems here, the capital projections, rates and timing are supplied; the task is to apply them consistently.

Why the Formula Holds

The risk margin is a value at time 0, while each cost-of-capital payment is a cash flow at a future date. By definition of a discount factor, a payment $K_t$ at time $t$ has present value $K_tD_t$. In this model, the payment for year $t$ is $K_t=cC_t$. Substituting this cash flow into the present-value calculation for all years gives

RM_0=\sum_{t=1}^{n}K_tD_t =\sum_{t=1}^{n}(cC_t)D_t.

This is a sum of discounted costs, not a sum of the capital requirements themselves. If $C_t=0$ for all projected years, the model gives $RM_0=0$. If the cost rate or any projected capital amount increases while all else is held fixed, the risk margin cannot decrease.

Calculating a Risk Margin

Worked Example: A Three-Year Capital Run-Off

A hypothetical long-term contract has projected capital requirements of $100,000 at the end of year 1, $70,000 at the end of year 2, and $30,000 at the end of year 3. The annual cost-of-capital rate is 6%, and the effective annual discount rate is 5%. Each cost is paid at the end of the year for which the capital requirement is stated. Calculate the risk margin.

Method. Calculate the cost for each year, discount each cost from its payment date to time 0, and add the present values.

Year 1. The cost is $0.06(100{,}000)=\$6{,}000$. Its present value is

\frac{\$6{,}000}{1.05}=\$5{,}714.2857.

Year 2. The cost is $0.06(70{,}000)=\$4{,}200$. Its present value is

\frac{\$4{,}200}{1.05^2} =\frac{\$4{,}200}{1.1025} =\$3{,}809.5238.

Year 3. The cost is $0.06(30{,}000)=\$1{,}800$. Its present value is

\frac{\$1{,}800}{1.05^3} =\frac{\$1{,}800}{1.157625} =\$1{,}554.9077.

The total before rounding is $\$5{,}714.2857+\$3{,}809.5238+\$1{,}554.9077=\$11{,}078.7172$. Thus the risk margin is $11,078.72, rounded to the nearest cent. As a check, it is positive and less than the undiscounted total cost of $10,000 only if that total is compared correctly: here the total cost is $12,000, so the discounted value of $11,078.72 is indeed lower.

Common mistake avoided. The year-3 cost is discounted for three years, not one year. The exponent is determined by the payment date relative to time 0.

Worked Example: Adding the Risk Margin to a Best-Estimate Liability

A hypothetical portfolio has a best-estimate liability of $420,000. Its projected capital requirements at the ends of years 1, 2 and 3 are $120,000, $90,000 and $45,000. The annual cost-of-capital rate is 6%, and the effective annual discount rate is 5%. Calculate the risk margin and, under the simplified definition above, the technical provisions.

Year 1. The cost is $0.06(120{,}000)=\$7{,}200$. Discounting one year gives $\$7{,}200/1.05=\$6{,}857.1429$.

Year 2. The cost is $0.06(90{,}000)=\$5{,}400$. Discounting two years gives

\frac{\$5{,}400}{1.05^2} =\frac{\$5{,}400}{1.1025} =\$4{,}897.9592.

Year 3. The cost is $0.06(45{,}000)=\$2{,}700$. Discounting three years gives

\frac{\$2{,}700}{1.05^3} =\frac{\$2{,}700}{1.157625} =\$2{,}332.3615.

Adding the three present values gives $RM_0=\$6{,}857.1429+\$4{,}897.9592+\$2{,}332.3615=\$14{,}087.4636$. The risk margin is therefore $14,087.46, rounded to the nearest cent.

Under the stated simplified definition, technical provisions are $\$420{,}000+\$14{,}087.46=\mathbf{\$434{,}087.46}$. The check is that the risk margin is added to—not substituted for—the best-estimate liability.

Common mistake avoided. Do not round an intermediate present value too early or carry an incorrect division into the total. In particular, $\$2{,}700/1.157625$ is approximately $\$2{,}332.3615$, not $\$2{,}332.7818$.

Varying Discount Rates and Payment Dates

Worked Example: Different Annual Discount Rates

For a hypothetical portfolio, capital requirements are $50,000 at the end of year 1, $40,000 at the end of year 2, and $20,000 at the end of year 3. The cost-of-capital rate is 4%. The effective discount rates are 4% in year 1, 5% in year 2, and 6% in year 3. Costs are paid at each year-end. Calculate the risk margin, reporting money to the nearest cent.

Year 1. The cost is $0.04(50{,}000)=\$2{,}000$. Its discount factor is $1/1.04$, so its present value is $\$2{,}000/1.04=\$1{,}923.0769$.

Year 2. The cost is $0.04(40{,}000)=\$1{,}600$. The accumulated discount factor uses both annual rates: $D_2=1/(1.04\times1.05)=1/1.092$. Thus the present value is $\$1{,}600/1.092=\$1{,}465.2015$.

Year 3. The cost is $0.04(20{,}000)=\$800$. The accumulated discount factor is $D_3=1/(1.04\times1.05\times1.06)=1/1.15752$. Thus the present value is $\$800/1.15752=\$691.1328$.

The total is $\$1{,}923.0769+\$1{,}465.2015+\$691.1328=\$4{,}079.4112$, giving a risk margin of $4,079.41 to the nearest cent. As a check, using only the year-3 rate to discount the third payment would ignore the accumulation from years 1 and 2 and would overstate that payment’s present value.

Timing, Interpretation, and Common Traps

The year attached to a projected capital amount must match the convention for the associated cost payment. In the examples above, $C_t$ generates a cost $cC_t$ paid at the end of year $t$. Some problems instead describe capital held over a period and a cost paid at the following period-end. In that case, identify the actual payment date first, then use the discount factor for that date. Do not select the exponent by counting capital projection rows alone.

For example, suppose $60,000 of capital is held from time 1 to time 2, the annual cost-of-capital rate is 6%, and the effective annual discount rate is 4%. If the $3,600 cost is paid at time 2, its present value is

\frac{\$3{,}600}{1.04^2} =\frac{\$3{,}600}{1.0816} =\$3{,}328.4024.

Discounting that payment by only one year would give $\$3{,}600/1.04=\$3{,}461.5385$, which is incorrect for a time-2 payment. Similarly, if $45,000 of capital generates a 6% cost paid at time 3 and the discount rate is 5%, the correct present value is $\$2{,}700/1.05^3=\$2{,}332.3615$.

Another frequent error is to add the capital requirements first and multiply by the cost rate, without discounting. For the three-year schedule in the second worked example, that shortcut gives $0.06(120{,}000+90{,}000+45{,}000)=\$15{,}300$. It is the undiscounted sum of costs, not their present value. The correct risk margin is $14,087.46 because the costs are paid in the future and discounted.

Key takeaway: Calculate each period’s cost from the capital requirement specified for that period, locate the cost’s payment date, discount it from that date to time 0, and then sum the present values. Add the resulting risk margin to the best-estimate liability only when the stated valuation definition calls for that construction.

Check Your Understanding

For each problem, use the stated end-of-year payment timing and round money to the nearest cent unless another instruction is given.

A hypothetical portfolio has capital requirements of $80,000 at time 1 and $40,000 at time 2, followed by zero. The cost-of-capital rate is 5% and the effective annual discount rate is 4%. Find the risk margin. (Answer: $5,695.27)
Capital requirements of $50,000 and $25,000 apply at the ends of years 1 and 2. The discount rate is 5%, and the risk margin is $3,000. Find the annual cost-of-capital rate, to two decimal places as a percentage. (Answer: 4.27%)
A hypothetical portfolio has capital requirements of $100,000 at time 1 and $60,000 at time 2. The cost-of-capital rate is 4%, and the effective annual discount rate is 5%. Find the risk margin. (Answer: $5,986.39)
A two-year projection has capital requirements of $40,000 and $20,000 at the ends of years 1 and 2. The effective annual discount rate is 5%. What annual cost-of-capital rate produces a risk margin of $2,500? Give the percentage to two decimal places. (Answer: 4.45%)

What You'll Learn