WACC With Preferred Stock and Multiple Debt Issues

Combining Multiple Financing Claims

A firm may finance itself with several bond or loan issues, preferred stock, and common equity. These claims can have different market values and required returns. To calculate the firm’s weighted average cost of capital, or WACC, treat each claim as a separate component: find its market value, divide by the market value of all included capital, and apply the return required by that claim’s investors.

The calculation is not an average of the quoted rates alone. A claim that represents a larger share of the firm’s financing receives a larger weight. Debt also requires careful tax treatment: when its interest is deductible and the firm can use the resulting tax benefit, the debt return in WACC is an after-tax return. Preferred dividends and common equity returns are not reduced by that interest tax adjustment.

Definition: Suppose a firm has $n$ debt issues with market values $D_j$ and before-tax required returns $k_{d,j}$, preferred stock with market value $P$ and required return $k_p$, and common equity with market value $E$ and required return $k_e$. Let $V=\sum_{j=1}^{n}D_j+P+E$. If all debt interest is deductible and the firm can use the tax benefit at the marginal corporate tax rate $T$, then $$ \mathrm{WACC}=\sum_{j=1}^{n}\frac{D_j}{V}k_{d,j}(1-T)+\frac{P}{V}k_p+\frac{E}{V}k_e. $$ If a particular debt issue does not produce a usable interest tax benefit, use its applicable before-tax return rather than multiplying that return by $1-T$. The formula assumes the included claims and their required returns are measured consistently.

For each issue, market value is the value of the investors’ claim at current market prices—not necessarily its face value, book value, or original proceeds. When a debt issue trades in an active market, its current yield to maturity is often the relevant estimate of its before-tax cost; the coupon rate is the contractual interest rate and need not equal that current required return. For preferred stock with a level annual dividend $D_p$ and current price $P_0$, a common cost estimate is $k_p=D_p/P_0$, under the assumption that the dividend is a level perpetuity.

Why the Weighted Formula Works

Each financing claim requires a return on the funds investors have supplied. Before tax effects, a claim with market value $M$ and required return $k$ represents an annual required return of $Mk$ on that capital. Adding these amounts across claims gives the total required return in dollars. Dividing by the total market value of capital converts that total into a rate.

\frac{\sum_j D_j k_{d,j}+P k_p+E k_e}{V} = \sum_j\frac{D_j}{V}k_{d,j}+\frac{P}{V}k_p+\frac{E}{V}k_e.

This is a market-value-weighted average because each numerator term is the return required on one category of capital and each denominator weight is that category’s fraction of total capital. When deductible interest creates a usable tax benefit, the after-tax financing cost of the debt issue is $k_{d,j}(1-T)$, so that adjusted return replaces the before-tax return for that issue. It would be inappropriate to apply the adjustment to preferred dividends or common equity returns: those payments are not deductible interest.

A useful check follows directly from the definition of $V$: the capital weights must sum to one. If they do not, an included claim may have been omitted, counted twice, or measured inconsistently.

Building the Calculation One Claim at a Time

List the financing claims.
Separate debt issues when their market values, required returns, or tax treatment differ. Include preferred stock and common equity when they are part of the financing being measured.

Find each market value.
Use the current market value of each issue. For a quoted bond, multiply the number of bonds by the quoted market price per bond; for equity, use the market value of the shares.

Calculate total capital and weights.
Add the included market values to get $V$, then divide each claim’s market value by $V$.

Assign the correct return.
Use an appropriate current required return for each debt issue, the preferred return for preferred stock, and the common equity return for common equity. Apply the interest tax adjustment only to debt for which its assumptions hold.

Weight, add, and check.
Multiply each weight by its applicable return, sum the contributions, and verify that the weights total one and the result is expressed as a rate.

Worked Example: Two Debt Issues, Preferred Stock, and Common Equity

A hypothetical firm has two debt issues with market values of $40 million and $30 million. Their current before-tax required returns are 5.0% and 7.0%, respectively. The firm also has $10 million of preferred stock with a required return of 8.0% and $70 million of common equity with a required return of 11.0%. Assume the corporate tax rate is 25%, and assume interest on both debt issues is deductible and the firm can use the tax benefit. Calculate WACC. The method is to calculate separate market-value weights and tax-adjust each debt return; this avoids treating the two debt issues as one issue with a single assumed cost.

Step 1: Total market value. In millions of dollars, $V=40+30+10+70=150$.

Step 2: Capital weights. The weights are $40/150=0.266667$ for the first debt issue, $30/150=0.200000$ for the second debt issue, $10/150=0.066667$ for preferred stock, and $70/150=0.466667$ for common equity. They sum to $1.000001$ using the displayed rounded weights; using the exact fractions, they sum to $(40+30+10+70)/150=1$.

Step 3: Applicable returns. The after-tax returns on the debt issues are $5.0\%(1-0.25)=3.75\%$ and $7.0\%(1-0.25)=5.25\%$. The preferred and common equity returns remain 8.0% and 11.0%.

Step 4: Weighted contributions. The contributions are $0.266667(3.75\%)=1.0000\%$, $0.200000(5.25\%)=1.0500\%$, $0.066667(8.0\%)=0.5333\%$, and $0.466667(11.0\%)=5.1333\%$. Adding the unrounded contributions gives $7.7167\%$, or 7.72% rounded to two decimal places.

Check. The four market values add to $150 million, their exact weights total one, and the four weighted contributions add to the stated WACC. No single debt rate was used for both issues.

Market Prices and Component Returns

A frequent source of error is to calculate the weights from current market values but use a return that describes a different basis. For debt, a bond’s coupon determines its contractual interest payments, while its current yield to maturity reflects the return investors require at its current market price, subject to the yield estimate’s assumptions. For preferred stock, the stated dividend per share is not itself the preferred return; it must be divided by the current market price per share.

Worked Example: Deriving Market Values from Issue Data

A hypothetical company has 800 bonds with a face amount of $1,000 each, quoted at 96% of face value, and an estimated current yield to maturity of 6.25%. It also has 300 bonds with a face amount of $1,000 each, quoted at 104% of face value, and an estimated current yield to maturity of 4.80%. Its preferred stock consists of 20,000 shares priced at $25 per share, each paying an annual dividend of $1.75. Common equity has a market value of $4.420 million and a required return of 10.50%. Assume the tax rate is 21%, both debt issues generate usable interest deductions, and preferred dividends are level. Find WACC. The method is to compute the market value and return for each claim before applying the weights; this avoids substituting face value or coupon rate for the relevant measure.

Step 1: Debt market values. The first bond price is $0.96($1,000)=$960$, so its market value is $800($960)=$768,000$. The second bond price is $1.04($1,000)=$1,040$, so its market value is $300($1,040)=$312,000$. Total debt market value is $1,080,000.

Step 2: Preferred market value and return. Preferred stock market value is $20,000($25)=$500,000$. The annual dividend per share is $1.75, so $k_p=$1.75/$25=0.0700$, or 7.00%.

Step 3: Total capital and weights. In thousands of dollars, total capital is $V=768+312+500+4,420=6,000$. The weights are $768/6,000=0.128$, $312/6,000=0.052$, $500/6,000=0.083333$, and $4,420/6,000=0.736667$.

Step 4: Tax-adjust debt and calculate WACC. The two after-tax debt returns are $6.25\%(1-0.21)=4.9375\%$ and $4.80\%(1-0.21)=3.7920\%$. The weighted contributions are $0.128(4.9375\%)=0.6320\%$, $0.052(3.7920\%)=0.197184\%$, $0.083333(7.00\%)=0.583333\%$, and $0.736667(10.50\%)=7.7350\%$. Their sum is $9.147517\%$, giving a WACC of 9.15% rounded to two decimal places.

Check. The market values total $6.000 million and the exact weights sum to one. The preferred return is based on its dividend divided by its price, not on its dividend alone.

Tax Treatment Must Match the Debt Issue

The tax adjustment represents the reduction in debt’s effective cost when deductible interest produces a tax benefit. It is not an automatic multiplier for every item labelled debt. The calculation must reflect the stated tax treatment and whether the firm can use the deduction. When the applicable assumptions do not hold for a particular issue, do not apply the tax reduction to that issue. Preferred dividends remain outside the interest tax adjustment even if the preferred stock has a fixed dividend.

Worked Example: One Debt Issue Has No Usable Interest Tax Benefit

A hypothetical company has $20 million of debt with a 4.5% required return and deductible interest that produces a usable tax benefit at a 25% tax rate. It also has $10 million of debt with an 8.0% required return; assume interest on this issue is not deductible under the stated tax treatment. Preferred stock has a market value of $5 million and a 5.0% required return. Common equity has a market value of $45 million and a required return of 9.5%. Calculate WACC. The method is to make the tax adjustment issue by issue; the common mistake is to apply the same tax factor to all debt without checking whether both issues qualify.

Step 1: Total capital and weights. Total capital is $V=20+10+5+45=$80$ million. The respective weights are $20/80=0.25$, $10/80=0.125$, $5/80=0.0625$, and $45/80=0.5625$; these sum to $1$.

Step 2: Assign returns. The deductible issue’s after-tax return is $4.5\%(1-0.25)=3.375\%$. The second issue receives no tax adjustment under the problem’s assumption, so its applicable return is 8.0%. The preferred and common equity returns are 5.0% and 9.5%.

Step 3: Weight each return. The contributions are $0.25(3.375\%)=0.84375\%$, $0.125(8.0\%)=1.00000\%$, $0.0625(5.0\%)=0.31250\%$, and $0.5625(9.5\%)=5.34375\%$. The sum is $7.50000\%$, so WACC is 7.50%.

Common mistake and correction. If the 8.0% return were incorrectly reduced to $8.0\%(1-0.25)=6.0\%$, its contribution would be $0.125(6.0\%)=0.750\%$, and the resulting WACC would be 7.25%. That answer understates WACC by 0.25 percentage points because it assumes a tax benefit that the problem explicitly rules out. Using the unadjusted 8.0% return gives the correct 7.50%.

Common Errors in a Multi-Issue Calculation

In a multi-claim WACC calculation, a small mistake in one component can affect both its weight and its contribution. Keep the market-value table and return calculations separate until each has been checked.

Using face value for weights. If a bond trades above or below face value, face value does not equal its current market value. Use the current quoted price to determine the market value of that issue.
Combining distinct debt costs too early. Debt issues with different required returns should each receive their own weight and return. They can be summarized only after their weighted contributions have been calculated.
Using the coupon as the current debt cost without support. The coupon is a contractual rate, not necessarily the current required return. Use the return measure specified by the problem or an appropriate current required-return estimate.
Tax-adjusting every financing return. The interest adjustment applies only where deductible interest produces a usable tax benefit. It does not apply to preferred dividends or common equity returns.
Using a preferred dividend as a return percentage. A dollar dividend must be divided by the preferred share’s current price to obtain the dividend yield under a level-dividend assumption.
Failing to check the weights. The exact market-value weights should sum to one. A failure to do so often signals an omitted claim, a duplicated value, or inconsistent units.

Key takeaway: For each financing claim, identify its market value, market-value weight, required return, and applicable tax treatment. Calculate separate weighted contributions, then add them. This method handles multiple debt issues and preferred stock without assuming that every claim has the same return or tax effect.

Check Your Understanding

For each problem, calculate WACC using the stated market values and tax assumptions. Round final rates to two decimal places.

A hypothetical firm has $24 million of debt costing 6.0%, $6 million of preferred stock with a required return of 8.0%, and $30 million of common equity costing 12.0%. Debt interest is deductible and the tax rate is 25%. (Answer: 8.60%)
A firm has two deductible debt issues with market values of $18 million and $12 million and required returns of 5.5% and 7.0%. It also has $10 million of preferred stock: each share costs $15 and pays an annual dividend of $0.90. Common equity is worth $60 million and costs 10.0%. The tax rate is 20%. (Answer: 8.06%)
A hypothetical company has $25 million of debt costing 6.4%, with deductible interest at a 25% tax rate; $15 million of debt costing 8.0%, with no usable interest tax benefit; $10 million of preferred stock costing 7.0%; and $50 million of common equity costing 11.0%. (Answer: 8.60%)
A company has 2,000 notes with a $1,000 face amount, a market quote of 97.5% of face, and a 5.2% required return. It also has 1,500 notes with a $1,000 face amount, a market quote of 102% of face, and a 6.8% required return. Preferred stock consists of 40,000 shares priced at $24 and paying $1.68 annually. Common equity is worth $15.56 million and costs 11.0%. Assume a 25% tax rate and usable interest deductions on both debt issues. (Answer: 9.66%)
A hypothetical firm has $35 million of deductible debt costing 6.2%, $25 million of deductible debt costing 7.4%, $15 million of preferred stock with an annual dividend of $2.10 per share and a market price of $30 per share, and $75 million of common equity costing 12.5%. The tax rate is 24%, and the interest tax benefits are usable. (Answer: 8.99%)

What You'll Learn